Home News Business Law Negotiating is One Thing, But Completing a Binding Contract is Quite Another

Negotiating is One Thing, But Completing a Binding Contract is Quite Another

Commercial negotiations may proceed for many months and involve any number of meetings, messages and phone calls. However, as a High Court ruling showed, the question of whether a binding contract has been completed very often hinges on whether a signature appears on a dotted line.

Over an extended period, a pharmaceutical company negotiated with a supplier with a view to being supplied with a muscle relaxant drug used in the treatment of multiple sclerosis. The company asserted that those negotiations resulted in a legally binding agreement and launched proceedings after the supplier entered into a distribution deal in respect of the drug with one of its competitors.

Dismissing the claim, however, the Court found that the negotiations had proceeded throughout on a ‘subject to contract’ basis. Offers had been made and accepted, but it was understood that no binding contract would come into existence until a formal addendum had been agreed and signed by both parties. Such an addendum had been reduced to writing, but the supplier never signed it.

Published in
Published
12 July 2021
Last Updated
7 March 2023